In the last few posts, we have discussed Samathavipasyana, the Five Aggregates, existential suffering, and grahyagrahakavikalpa and verified the illusional nature of physical reality. In this post, we tie them all together by exploring how a well-known Avalokiteśvara liberated himself from his existential suffering by practicing Samathavipasyana so profoundly that he comprehended the root cause of existential suffering by understanding the Emptiness of the Five Aggregates.
First, let’s understand what Emptiness is in Buddhism.
Emptiness (Romanized Sanskrit=shunyata/sunyata; Chinese=空), according to The Dictionary Shambhala Dictionary of Buddhism and Zen, also known as “void,” is a “central notion of Buddhism….Shunyata is often equated with the absolute in the Mahayana since it is without duality and empirical forms.”
- As shall be discussed, the absolute in Buddhism is the Ultimate Reality, a realm of quiescent mentality spread throughout the cosmos. By definition, quiescent mentality is the realm of awareness that Adyashanti realized upon his enlightenment.
- “Void” and “Without empirical forms” both signify that mentality cannot be seen, heard, smelled, tasted, or touched.
- Buddha describes the Ultimate Reality as Inconceivable, which, according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, means “beyond conceptualization.”
- As discussed earlier, “the importance of “beyond all conceptualization” is that even if mentality becomes “reading in of the mind,” it cannot be conceptualized “in ways we do not govern,” two of the sensing steps Dr. Fisch described in “How Do We Know What We Know.” Without conceptualization, mentality cannot become a visible phenomenon, so it cannot be seen, heard, smelled, tasted, or touched.” Another example of something that is beyond conceptualizaton is natural gas.
- “Without duality” means that, in Buddha’s cosmos, where there is “Nothing but Mentality,” duality is delusional.
Before discussing the content of Mahasattva Avalokiteśvara’s experience, let’s first clarify the meaning of some relevant terms that will be used in this discussion.
1) Heart_Sutra (Chinese=/心經) “is a popular sutra in Mahayana Buddhism.” “It has been called “the most frequently used and recited text in the entire Mahayana Buddhist tradition.” “In Sanskrit, the title Prajñāpāramitāhṛdaya translates as “The Heart of the Perfection of Wisdom (Chinese=般若波羅蜜多心經).” It is a highly significant Buddhist text in Mahayana Buddhism because it shows how one can satisfy Buddha’s soteriological mission and liberate oneself from existential suffering by understanding the Emptiness of the Five Aggregates.
2) Perfection of Wisdom is known in Romanized Sanskrit as Prajnaparamita, a combination of prajna and paramita.
Prajna (Chinese=般若), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, typically translated “wisdom,” “the term has the general sense of accurate and precise understanding but is used most often to refer to an understanding of reality that transcends ordinary comprehension.”
Paramita (Chinese=波羅蜜多), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, “perfection,” a virtue or quality developed and practiced by a Bodhisattva on the path to becoming a Buddha. The term is paranomastically glossed by some traditional commentators as “gone beyond” or “gone to the other side” although it seems, in fact, to derive from Skt. “parama,” meaning “highest” or supreme.”
When combined, Prajnaparamita (Chinese=般若波羅蜜多/智度), meaning the Perfection of Wisdom, is the supreme wisdom gained from “an understanding of reality that transcends ordinary comprehension,” achieved through the most profound practice of samathavipasyana.
Samathavipasyana (Chinese=止觀), as discussed in a previous post, is a method of practicing direct perception, a unique method Buddha taught to understand the world of mentality by becoming part of it. When one becomes part of the world of mentality, it makes it possible for the enlightened to perceive it directly and have “an understanding of reality that transcends ordinary comprehension.”
3) The Heart Sutra is considered the Heart of the Perfection of Wisdom sutras because this extremely short but influential Sutra summarizes the core teachings of the whole collection of Prajnaparamita sutras by using the experience of Mahabodhisattva Avalokiteśvara’s liberation from his existential suffering.
4) Mahabodhisattva (Chinese=摩訶菩薩), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, “great bodhisattva.” These “great bodhisattvas” are the bodhisattvas close to achieving the highest level of enlightenment, such as Avalokiteśvara.
5) Avalokiteśvara “is a tenth-level bodhisattva associated with great compassion (mahakaruṇā). He is often associated with Amitabha Buddha.” A tenth-level bodhisattva is the highest level of Bodhisattva. After finishing the tenth level, a bodhisattva is ready to “attain full Buddhahood,” known as a Tathagata. Avalokiteśvara is also known as Guanyin (Chinese=觀音菩薩) in East Asia.
The Heart Sutra refers Bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara as Vasita.
Vasita (Chinese=自在), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, “mastery,” or “autonomy;” a list of ten types of master or autonomy developed by a Bodhisattva, viz., of one’s life span (命自在), action (Karman) (業自在), necessities of life (財自在), determination (如意自在), aspiration (願自在), magical powers (信解自在), birth (生自在), dharma (法自在), mind (心自在) and wisdom (智自在).”
In Mahayana Buddhism, complete attainment of the ten masteries is reserved for all tenth-level Bodhisattvas. Therefore, vasita should apply not only to Avalokiteśvara but to all ten-level Bodhisattvas, who, similar to Bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara, are close to liberating themselves and satisfying Buddha’s soteriological goal.
The Heart Sutra starts as follows:
“The Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara, as he practices the Perfection of Wisdom profoundly, gained an illuminating insight into the Emptiness of all the Five Aggregates, thus realizing that this is the way to relieve all beings from sufferings.” (Chinese=觀自在菩薩, 行深般若波羅蜜多時. 照見五蘊皆空, 度一切苦厄.”
Immediately after his proclamation that all the Five Aggregates are Empty, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara told Sariputra (Chinese=舍利子) the following lines that make the Heart Sutra “the single most commonly recited, copied, and studied scripture in East Asian Buddhism.” The Heart Sutra is so popular because some suggest these four lines below are compatible with Einstein’s famous formula, E=mc2. However, they are only compatible if mentality replaces energy in Einstein’s formula.
Sariputra (Chinese=舍利子) is “one of the top disciples of the Buddha. He is considered the first of the Buddha’s two chief male disciples, together with Maudgalyāyana (Chinese=目犍連).“
Rupa is no different than emptiness (Chinese=色不異空).
Emptiness is no different than rupa. (Chinese=空不異色).
Rupa is just emptiness (Chinese=色即是空).
Emptiness is just rupa. (Chinese=空即是色)
So are the four other Aggregates (Chinese=sho受想行識亦復如是).”
As discussed in the last post, rupa (Chinese=色), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit and Pali, “body,” “form,” or “materiality,” viz., that which has shape and is composed of matter. More generally, rupa refers to materiality, which serves as the object of the five sensory consciousness (vijnana): visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, and tactile.” In other words, rupa represents the material world that humans experience through seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, and touching.
By unequivocally and repeatedly equating rupa and emptiness through the understanding of the Five Aggregates, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara shows his understanding that rupas are mental because they are “mere projections of consciousness,” the fourth of the Five Aggregates. This is the meaning of Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara’s next saying in the Heart Sutra, “All phenomena are the manifestations of Emptiness (Chinese=是諸法空相).”
In other words, the phenomenal world is illusional because everything is a mere projection of consciousness. Without the projections of consciousness, the phenomena world does not exist. It is a phenomenon that any enlightened person, such as the enlightened contemporary American Adyashanti and others, can verify when the phenomenal world disappears upon their enlightenment. However, while enlightened people understand that the physical universe is illusional, they do not know why it is illusional. Only when one understands the Emptiness of the Five Aggregates can one comprehend that the phenomenal world is illusional because everything in it is a mere projection of consciousness.
Indeed, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara’s realization that all phenomena are illusional is compatible with Buddha’s teaching in the Diamond Sutra.
In the Diamond Sutra, Buddha says:
“All conditioned dharmas are like the illusions of dreams, shadows of bubbles (Chinese=一切有為法，如夢幻泡影)
Like dews and lightning, they should be understood this way (Chinese=如露亦如電，應作如是觀).”
With his understanding that all the Five Aggregates are empty, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara is aware that he has liberated himself from his existential sufferings. Being “a tenth-level bodhisattva associated with great compassion,” the first thing that comes to Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara’s mind is that it “is the way to relieve all from sufferings.”
After summarizing his findings, the Bodhisattva continues: “There is no birth or death, no defilement or purity, no adding or subtracting (Chinese=不生不滅, 不垢不淨, 不增不減.”).
Furthermore, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara goes on to mention a list of Buddha’s doctrines, such as the Five Aggregates (Chinese=色受想行識), the Six Sensory Bases (Chinese=眼耳鼻舌身意), Their Six Corresponding Sense Objects (Chinese=色聲香味觸法), Unenlightenment (Chinese=無明), End of Enlightenment (Chinese=無明盡), Aging and Death (Chinese=老死), End of Aging or Death (Chinese=無老死), Four Truths for the Nobles (苦集滅道), etc., and deem them all “nil (Chinese=無).”
These Buddhist teachings are “nil” in Emptiness because no phenomena exist in the Ultimate Reality, where mentality does not fluctuate. Only a fluctuating mentality gives rise to phenomena. Furthermore, since the Ultimate Reality is inconceivable, it is also ineffable. Therefore, Buddha’s verbal teachings can only provide “ordinary “comprehension,” but not an “accurate and precise understanding.” Thus, Buddha teaches that to understand the Ultimate Reality, one must perceive it directly.
Indeed, to help someone understand the Ultimate Reality, Buddha needs only to teach Samathavipasyana. When one practices samathavipasyana successfully, one can learn from the Ultimate Reality directly through wordless transmission.
Let’s discuss Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara’s statement, “No birth or death, no turbidity or purity, no addition or subtraction.” The statement reflects the second part of the definition of Emptiness, i.e., the Ultimate Reality is “without duality.” It is a concept known in Romanized Sanskrit as grahyagrahakavikalpa.
Grahyagrahakavikalpa (Chinese=所取能取分別), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, “discrimination between the grasped and the grasper,” or “false conception of apprehended and the apprehender,” a special kind of discrimination (Vikalpa) used in the Yogacara school to refer to the misconception that there is an inherent bifurcation between a perceiving subject (grahaka) and its perceived object (grahya).”
Like Emptiness, Suchness (Romanized Sanskrit=Tathaga, Chinese=真如) is “a term for ultimate reality,” but from a different perspective. The definition of Suchess contains the following, “In Yogacara/Vijnanavada, the term refers to the ultimate wisdom that is free from the subject-object distinction (grahyagrahakavikalpa)” “In the Madhyamaka school, any attempt to substantiate the nature of reality is rejected, and tathata is instead identified with Emptiness and the cessation of all dichotomizing tendencies of thought.”
In other words, the ultimate wisdom in Buddhism is identified with “the cessation of all dichotomizing tendencies of thought” and “free from the subject-object distinction.”
By stating that there is “No birth or death, no turbidity or purity, no addition or subtraction,” Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara shows he has attained the ultimate wisdom because he has ceased his “dichotomizing tendencies of thought.”
As Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara continues, he talks about the fruitions of attaining the ultimate wisdom.
With everything “nil,” Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara concludes that “there is nothing to possess (Chinese=無所得).” However, having nothing to possess is not bad, as Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara continued, “Because there is nothing to possess, the Bodhisattvas, relying on the practice of the perfection of wisdom, become carefree. Being carefree and without fear (the Bodhisattvas) are far from topsy-turvy reveries and ultimately enter Nirvana. Buddhas of past, present, and future(Romanized Sanskrit=tirkala; Chinese=三世), relying on practicing the perfection of wisdom, realize anuttara-samyak-sambodhi. (Chinese=以無所得故，菩提薩埵, 依般若波羅蜜多故, 心無罣礙, 無罣礙故, 無有恐怖, 遠離顛倒夢想, 究竟涅槃. 三世諸佛, 依般若波羅蜜多故, 得阿搙多羅三藐三菩提).”
As discussed previously, Anuttara-samyak-sambodhi (Chinese=阿搙多羅三藐三菩提)” is “in Sanskrit, “unsurpassed (anuttara), complete (samyak) and perfect enlightenment (sambodhi).”
Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara is very clear that by “relying on practicing the perfection of wisdom,” he “realizes anuttara-samyak-sambodhi,” which allows him to realize the “ultimate wisdom.” By realizing the “ultimate wisdom,” Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara realizes that there is no “subject-object distinction,” which allows him to declare there is “No birth or death, no turbidity or purity, no addition or subtraction.”
With his delusional misunderstanding gone and the ultimate wisdom achieved, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara can be “far from topsy-turvy reveries” and be ready to enter “Nirvana.”
Nirvana (Chinese=涅槃), according to The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism, is “in Sanskrit, “extinction,” the earliest and most common term describing the soteriological goal of Buddhism.”
So, what is Buddha’s soteriological goal?
In the Lotus Sutra, Buddha stated his soteriological goal clearly as below:
“I initially vowed.
To make all sentient beings my equal without a difference.
Now that I have fulfilled this vow
That I made in the past.
I can transform them.
So they all enter the path of Buddhahood.”
In other words, Buddha aspired for everyone to be a Tathagata, which is “his equal without a difference.”
Indeed, by practicing the Perfection of Wisdom and realizing the Emptiness of the Five Aggregates, Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara gains the ultimate wisdom and is ready to be a Tathagata.
However, the path from attaining the ultimate wisdom to becoming a Tathagata may still take some time.
Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara still had to eliminate latent tendencies (Romanized Sanskrit =vasana; Chinese=習氣); habituations accumulated over innumerable previous cycles of samsara. However, getting rid of habituation does not require work (Chinese=無功用道). As long as no additional habituations are incurred, getting rid of habituations is like getting rid of the smell from an open wine barrel; it happens naturally with time.
Given that Nirvana describes “the soteriological goal of Buddhism,” it is critical to understand Nirvana accurately. As Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara’s example shows, entering the final Nirvana represents an elevation in enlightenment and wisdom. It is certainly not to be confused with “achieved at death,” as some like to believe.
With everything Nothing but Mentality in the cosmos, the journey in Buddhism is mental, not physical. Buddha’s aspiration for all to enter Nirvana is, without a doubt, not an aspiration for anyone who has achieved the highest level of Buddhahood with extreme effort and time only to be met by the death of an illusional physical body that is but a “mere projects of consciousness.”
What Nirvana extinct is the delusional misunderstanding of reality. When one attains the ultimate wisdom of a Tathagata, one realizes that not only is there no Mind-Body problem in nature, but “all dichotomizing tendencies of thought” must also be ceased. Only then can one be a Tathagata, be like our Buddha, satisfy his soteriological goal, live a “carefree and without fear” life, and be “far from topsy-turvy reveries,” as Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara testified.
(If you like this post, please like it on our Facebook page and share. Thank you.)
